A viral video by influencer Sarthak Sachdeva alleging “fake paneer” at a high-end Mumbai restaurant has reignited public scrutiny around the quality of paneer served in Indian eateries. While the restaurant clarified its paneer contains soy, the controversy has highlighted a broader, more troubling industry trend: the widespread use of adulterants and additives in dairy products. Experts warn that such ingredients not only compromise nutritional value but may also pose health risks over time. As food costs rise and demand for bulk production increases, understanding the difference between authentic paneer and its commercial counterparts has never been more vital.
The Controversy That Sparked a Debate
A seemingly routine iodine test conducted by food influencer Sarthak Sachdeva on paneer at Torii, a posh Mumbai restaurant owned by producer-designer Gauri Khan, sent social media into a frenzy. The test showed a bluish-black hue—widely understood to indicate the presence of starch. Although the restaurant responded by explaining its paneer includes soy ingredients, not starch, the incident raised a pertinent question: how many eateries serve authentic, unadulterated paneer?
According to dietetics experts, the use of binding agents and texturizers—such as starch, maida (refined flour), arrowroot, milk powder, and even synthetic milk—is now a common practice to enhance the volume, texture, and shelf life of paneer.
Nutritional Degradation in Modified Paneer
Traditional paneer, when made from fresh whole milk, is a rich source of high-quality protein, healthy fats, calcium, phosphorus, and essential vitamins like B12 and D. However, introducing additives alters its nutritional composition significantly.
Adding starchy or fatty fillers can:
- Increase carbohydrate and fat content disproportionately
- Reduce protein density, which is paneer’s primary nutritional benefit
- Diminish micronutrient levels, particularly calcium and vitamin D
- Alter the glycemic index, potentially affecting blood sugar levels
These modifications not only weaken the health benefits of paneer but may also create a misleading impression of its dietary value.
Short-Term and Long-Term Health Risks
Paneer adulterated with starch and synthetic fats may appear harmless, but frequent consumption can result in a series of short-term and potentially long-term health concerns.
Short-term effects include:
- Digestive discomfort such as bloating, constipation, or diarrhea
- Increased caloric intake without corresponding nutritional gain
- Hormonal imbalances triggered by certain chemical compounds
Long-term risks could include:
- Elevated cholesterol due to saturated or trans fats
- Weight gain linked to hidden sugars and carbohydrates
- Potential kidney or liver damage from continuous chemical exposure
While conclusive long-term studies are still awaited, health professionals recommend erring on the side of caution.
How to Identify and Avoid Adulterated Paneer
Several home-based tests and label checks can help consumers distinguish between real and analogue (fake) paneer:
- Iodine Test: A bluish-black color suggests the presence of starch.
- Boiling Test: Paneer that melts or leaves an oily residue likely contains synthetic ingredients.
- Label Scrutiny: Authentic paneer should list only milk and a natural coagulant (e.g., citric acid). If it mentions vegetable fat, starch, or preservatives, it is not pure paneer.
Shifting Toward Healthier Alternatives
As food safety becomes a growing concern, experts advocate for making paneer at home using whole milk from reliable sources. Homemade paneer not only ensures purity but also allows better control over texture and flavor.
In addition to this, incorporating plant-based proteins—such as lentils, tofu, chickpeas, and soy—alongside fiber-rich vegetables can balance out protein intake without over-relying on dairy. Moderation remains key, especially when dining out or consuming heavily processed foods.
Final Thoughts
The paneer incident may have started with a viral clip, but it has led to a much-needed conversation around food integrity in India's bustling restaurant industry. As consumers become more health-conscious, the demand for clean, transparent food sourcing will only grow. For now, being aware of what’s on your plate—and how it’s made—may be the most powerful form of nutritional self-defense.
Comments